Discuss shalabh's I-140 USCIS Case

Hi Shalabh, congrates! I am in the same boat as you. I received RFE few days ago, asking additional evidence in all catagories. I don't know what to do. Can you please provide more information about your case. Please also indicate what did you send in RFE reply.

Bulldog,
I contested the following categories:

1) Membership in a society - Nomination in SigmaXi (USCIS accepted)

2) Reviewer of others work - Reviewed 4 journal/conf papers and got letter from editors (RFE required to prove how I got acclaim by doing this)
RFE reply- Proved that I was asked to review 4 additional papers based on my contribution earlier. Further proved that I was invited as a panelist for an intl conf. (satisfies international acclaim)

3) Original scientific work - Provided copies of 12+ journal/conf papers that I published. Primary inventor of 1 US patent. Submitted 8 letters of reference with 2 from independent evaluators.

4) Leading role in an organization - Proved that I am one of only 2 PhDs in my company that are working on a niche field. My manager wrote about my contributions and my importance to my company.

My attorney proved that I have a PhD from a top 5 engineering schools in US and that I work in a niche field where very few PhDs are present.
I did not submit a list of citations as there are very few (2).

Hope it helps!

shalabh,

Was the notice you received an RFE or a NOID (notice of intent ot deny)..Because I'm in the NOID boat that's worrying me really.

Thanks for your posting.

NOID is sent to DENY the application. Mine was RFE (request for additional information).

Hey Shalabh, I have done self petition and need to answer my RFE. If possible can i know how did you reply your RFE. Thanks

Hi Shalabh
Can elaborate on what kind of evidence you provided for the following-
"My attorney proved that I have a PhD from a top 5 engineering schools in US and that I work in a niche field where very few PhDs are present. I did not submit a list of citations as there are very few (2)."
In other words, what kind of documentation was deemed appropriate for this.
Thanks for your help.